Loading, Please Wait...
aA
Daily Journal
     December 4, 2020      #95-339 KDJ
 

Fat 'jokes' unfair way to criticize

By Scott Reeder

SPRINGFIELD — We live in a society where it is unacceptable to ridicule a candidate’s race or religion, but increasingly a politician’s size is fair game.

As politics has become increasingly mean spirited, fat “jokes” have become more commonplace. Politicians such as former New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie, Gov. J.B. Pritzker and, yes, Donald Trump, are subjected to mockery because of their weight.

Here’s what Democratic consultant James Carville had to say about Trump earlier this year on a podcast: “He’s a big fat loser, alright. He’s so fat.”

Regular readers of this column know that I’m no fan of Trump. But I find no humor in these remarks. And, yes, I realize Trump has done much to coarsen public discourse during the last five years. Still, criticize his ideas, his positions on issues but not his belt size.

Much the same can be said of the cutting remarks I’ve heard about Pritzker.

Commentary on an Illinois conservative website alternately refers to him as “Jelly Bean,” “Jelly Belly” and “Jelly Biscuit.”

Hey, I get it. You don’t like his stand on taxes or the pandemic. But what does his weight have to do with those issues? Nothing.

Unsuccessful legislative candidate Peter Breen suggested to me several months ago that the reason Pritzker wasn’t venturing out of Chicago more was because of his “co-morbidity.”

After a long pause, I said, “Are you saying he’s too fat?” His response: yes.

Sorry, Peter. I’m not a fan of some of the governor’s positions either. That said, he has been an engaged governor who works hard. He’s actively working and available — more than most of his recent predecessors. I’ve seen no indication that he is anyway impaired in getting his job done.

So, talk about his fiscal policies, not his physical size.

When I supervised statehouse reporters in various states, I had a reporter in Trenton, N.J., who routinely referred to Christie as “Gov. Krispy Kreme” during our daily staff meetings. I bit my tongue on a near daily basis wanting to say, “Do you realize how stupid and petty that makes you sound?”

In hindsight, I should have spoken up.

After more than 30 years of covering politicians, I can say usually those who joke about obesity are folks who have never struggled with it themselves.

I know the struggle. At one point, I weighed 100 pounds more than I do today. Although I’m now at a healthy weight, I’m humble enough to realize the recidivism rate on weight loss is frighteningly high.

Over the past 33 years, my weight has yo-yoed more than a Duncan Butterfly. It’s a daily struggle.

Obesity isn’t a personal failing, it’s a disease.

Early in my career, I had a supervisor who continually ridiculed my weight and inferred that I and several other overweight reporters had no business in “his” newsroom.

He was not a nice person. But he was the boss, and I just had to sit there and take it.

It always seemed to me that what I wrote, how I reported or how I otherwise conducted myself as an employee was fair game for him to judge. But what business was it of his — or anyone else’s — what my suit size was?

Well, we’re these politicians’ bosses. Let’s evaluate them the way we would like to be judged. Let’s look at their performance, policies and positions and leave the measuring tape at home.

Scott Reeder is a veteran statehouse journalist and a freelance reporter.His email address is ScottReeder1965@gmail.com.

1 of 1
X

Scott Reeder
With the Clean Ticket Company, your money goes to those who do the work!
Nancy on BROTHER GEORGE BBQ @ 12/14/2020
well written...makes me hungry!
Nancy on Kankakee awarded… @ 12/14/2020
Can't hurt.....
Nancy on Scott Reeder:… @ 12/14/2020
good points by Scott
Ursala on Gary Moore:… @ 10/14/2020
"It's a comment.", he says.
Ursala on A historic… @ 10/14/2020
Comment section.
Ursala on Scott Reeder:… @ 10/01/2020
Post your thoughts or opinions here.
Ursala on Gary Moore: Are you… @ 09/17/2020
Great
Ursala on Manteno native's… @ 09/17/2020
Awesome!
shadow on Region's… @ 09/09/2020
Excellent article
shadow @ November 15, 2020, 6:18 pm
I fully agree.
Ursala on Bradley Elementary… @ 09/03/2020
Post your comments for the world to see!
12